Skip to article

Why is tax withheld different from tax owed?

Updated Nov 17, 2026Updated Nov 17, 2026

Tax withheld from your pay, withdrawals, or Roth conversions goes toward your yearly tax bill. When you file, you get a refund if you paid too much, or pay the difference if you paid too little.

Your plan works the same way. The difference shows up the following year as a Tax Refund or a Tax Return Payment, which is why the tax paid in Cash Flow can differ from the tax owed in Tax Analytics.

Find the difference in your plan

Open the year on Plan > Overview, then open Show metrics and find Tax Balance. It shows this year’s estimated tax balance after withholding, to be settled next year. If the metric is hidden, open Display Options > Metrics, turn on Show Metrics, and include it under Which Metrics.

A selected year in Plan Overview with the Tax Balance breakdown showing tax owed and amounts paid.

For the total tax estimate, open Tax Analytics. For money actually paid or refunded, look at Cash Flow.

Set withholding to match your pay and withdrawals

Open Settings > Tax > Withholding. Set the rates for Tax-Deferred Withdrawals, Taxable Withdrawals, and Conversions to match how tax leaves your accounts.

For early Roth conversions where withholding would trigger a penalty, ProjectionLab converts the full amount and settles the tax through the following year’s tax payment instead.

Tax Withholding settings for pre-tax withdrawals, taxable withdrawals, and conversions.

Income has its own withholding choices. Open a salary, pension, or other income under Plan > Income, then Tax Handling, to use an automatic estimate, a fixed rate, or no withholding where supported.

Extra withholding becomes a refund in the next year. Withholding that falls short becomes a payment then. A conversion with little withholding can leave a larger bill to cover the following year.

If something looks off

Why didn’t changing withholding change my tax bill?

Withholding changes when you pay tax. Your final estimated tax still depends on that year’s income and deductions.

How do I include tax from before my plan began?

Add a payment you still owe as a one-time expense in the first year. For a tax-free refund, add one-time Custom Income and turn on Tax-Exempt under Tax Handling.

Next: Explore a year in Tax Analytics

Need a hand?

Try it in your own plan

Simulate your financial future and chart a course toward your best life.

Disclaimer: The content, tools, and resources on ProjectionLab.com are intended solely for informational and educational purposes and should not be construed as professional financial or investment advice. Our materials are designed to provide general guidance and are based on the input and data provided by users. ProjectionLab makes no guarantee of the accuracy, completeness, or applicability of this content to individual circumstances. Effective financial planning and investment involve comprehensive consideration of a wide array of personal financial factors. The tools and resources available on ProjectionLab are aimed at helping users develop an understanding of their financial trajectory. However, they should not be solely relied upon for creating a complete financial plan. We strongly recommend consulting a financial services professional who can provide personalized advice based on your unique financial situation before making any significant financial decisions. While we endeavor to keep the information on ProjectionLab current and accurate, the content may differ from that found on other financial institutions, service providers, or specific product sites. All content and tools on ProjectionLab are provided without any guarantees or warranties of any kind.